"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Herrmann 3-112: Introduction-Chapter 3

Chapter 1: The European Armies in 1904

The European armies of 1904 still looked very much like those of the 19th century.

"Much of the armies had fairly recent experience of waging colonial wars or suppressing uprisings in their own territories, but this did not give an accurate indication of what a big European conflict would look like. Beneath the surface of armies' traditional exteriors lurked considerable mysteries for anyone who tried to predict how these forces would perform the task for which they were designed" (11).

Because of conscription, it was hard to judge what sort of force a given peacetime army would produce when mobilizing for war.

Rapid changes in technology complicated the effectiveness of armies and war plans. The fact that new equipment was available was obvious. The effect that it would have on the future was a matter of lively debate.

1896: Two Frenchmen create a field gun carriage that remained stationary in firing.
1884: Machine gun, United States
Other technologies: automobile, fixed wireless radio stations, telephones, tethered balloons, aviation

A Russian officer in 1906 said that the charge with the bayonet remained the essence of combat, and that "it is force of moral which will bring victory" (28)

"The wars of the future would be wars of entire peoples, aimed not at the capture of fotresses or territory but at the total destruction of the enemy: 'absolute war,' as Clausewitz himself had defined it" (28).

Constraints the armies faced:
France: government suspicion and political animosity.
Russia: loss against Japan.
Austria-Hungary: domestic disputes.

Chapter 2: The European Armies and the First Moroccan Crisis, 1905-1906

In the summer of 1905 the German government threatened France with war. The Moroccan Crisis did not lead to war, but it lead to a loss of power on Germany's part, and the entente between France and Britain.

The British realized that they needed to be prepared for a land war in Europe.

Chapter 3: Military Effectiveness and Modern Technology, 1906-1908

The introduction of new technology made it harder for armies to challenge each other with expansions.

Constraints on Military Expansion After the Moroccan Crisis

While the French had faced the greatest alarm, they did not devote substantially increased resources to its army. The French began looking to Britain and Russia for possible military cooperation. Even though Russia agreed to help, military experts agree that Russia was incapable of fighting an offensive war throughout the period from 1906 to 1908. The Russian army slowly grew, despite the obstacle of the new parliament (the duma). Also looking across the Channel for help, the British soon realized that their imperial forces must be able to also fight a land war in Europe.

The Influence of New Technology on Military Development

The need to modernize equipment was another pressure on the European armies. The necessary action was a gradual modernization of equipment. The French tended to be the most energetic pioneers of new technology.

"...while military experts concurred that machine guns would be necessary, it was harder to agree on just what they would be necessary for. It was clear that they would be essential for defense against an enemy armed with machine guns" (70).

There was also a transition from brightly colored uniforms to khakis and greens. In addition, officers began dressing more like their men, as to avoid being picked out. This was met with much resistance from many, but was eventually accepted.