Frevert's thesis is "that the language of honor as it was traditionally spoken in time of strife was badly suited to solving the massive conflicts in 1914." He also argues that the pathos stemmed from gendered images of honor that appealed directly to people emotions.
I. From Personal Honor to National Honor: Duels and Wars
Almost all of the documents produced during the crucial stages of decision making in the summer of 1914 alluded to honor. The documents themselves are "indistinguishable and interchangeable." All politicians claimed that by declaring war they were acting in defense (the attack affected the very honor of the nation).
I really enjoyed Clausewitz's comparison of war to "an extended duel" and Frevert's subsequent argument against Clausewitz's comparison.
After the French Revolution, politics and war were nationalized through the descruction of monarcial power.
II. Honor and Gender
The language of honor as it was spoken among diplomats was highly assocaited with gender images because both the fatherland and the family were described in feminine terms. Men were protecting female "honor" (chastity) by protecting the homeland. Frevert claims that this "common understanding of a gender-specific honor made it easier in 1914 to rally support for the decision to go to war." He defends this by sourcing several examples of "gendered images of strong and courageous men protecting weak women."
III. Honor, Shame, and No Compromise: A Conclusion
1. Honor was a main concern of those deciding between war and peace.
2. The language of weakness and strength often contained heavily gendered undertones.
Frevert claims that "the language spoken and the metaphore used made it extremely difficult to find a compromise in the diplomatic exchanges preceding the declarations of war" and "given the genedered nature of honor, stepping back is extremely difficult and generally associated with weakness."
I think this is a really interesting arguement. I like the importance of language. I feel like that is something that historians often shy away from exploring. The arguement itself seems to be lacking in substantive defense.