"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Thursday, October 14, 2010

French Workers and German Workers: The Impossibility of Internationalism, 1900-1914, Jolyon Howorth

Main point: "to place working-class nationalism at the forefront of historical inquiry"

In the introduction, the author points out weaknesses in traditional approaches.

I. Nationalism and internationalism among workers: assumptions and definitions

Through an examination of the French workers' attempt at internationalism, Howorth will assess the resurgence of a deep-rooted nationalism.

Why did the workers turn towards internationalism? "an eagerness to learn from experience derived elsewhere and to apply at home lessons learned abroad."

II. French Workers and Nationalist Conditioning after 1870

After the loss to Germany in 1870, an intense nationalistic propaganda campaign infiltrated French society. This created a strong xenophobia in French workers.

III. The CGT and international labor links, 1900-1914

Here Howorth followed the patterns of international labor relations between the CGT and the German equivalent.

Conclusions

It is easy to be "internationalist" at home, but it is more difficult to make it actually happen.

There is the same problem today as back then: reconciling nationalism with internationalism.