"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Monday, October 4, 2010

Herrmann 172-232: Chapters 6-7

Chapter 6: The Balkan Wars and the Spiral of Armaments, 1912-1913

The First Balkan War broke out when Montenegro declared war on the Ottoman Empire. This flung the Balkan states into a struggle to conquer all the lands the Ottomans still controlled in the Balkans. The war was a disaster for the Turks. Within a month of the outbreak of hostilities the Ottomans had lost almost all of their European land. The Second Balkan War in the summer of 1913 occurred as the victors fought among themselves over the distribution of the territory. The First and Second Balkan Wars brought a fresh sense of urgency to the armament race.

Reactions to the German Army Law and the Balkan Wars

Before the start of the Balkan Wars, there was already an armament race (it was mainly land armaments now, as opposed to the naval races of a few years prior).

In France, the armament race was facilitated by the nationalist revival that followed the Moroccan crisis. During the crisis, the press had portrayed France's greatness as being at state. All the Entente powers took extensive measures to both strengthen their armies and cement their joint strategy. The French boasted two leading Entente military figures in September of 1912: Sir Henry Wilson and Grand Duke Nicholas Nikolaevich. Also, the French managed to gain committment from Grey to consult on joint military plans if war threatened in November of 1912.

The new balance of power that the war brought about transformed the atmosphere of tension into one of emergency.

The Balkan Wars electrified Vienna. A war with Russia was seen as very likely and many of the leaders contemplated crushing Serbia while it was still possible. The Austro-Hungarian leaders knew, however, that Russia would join in and cause a general European conflict.

In Berlin too, the Balkan conflict led to talk of a general war. Moltke expressed the view that since a gneral war was inevitable, it would be better to fight it at once rather than later. On December 8, 1912, the "War Council" that Fischer places so much focus on occurred.

The German Reaction to the Balkan Wars: The 1913 Army Law

The German reaction to the Balkan Wars was a fresh round of army expansion. The outbreak of the First Balkan War raised the level of excitement and added fresh fuel to the ultra nationalist agitation. France and Russia together had 827,000 more soldiers than Germany and Austria-Hungary.

There was an argument about how to increase the size of the military. It was resolved by increases the forces by one-sixth.

The Reaction of the Entente: The French Three-Year Law and Russian Army Increases

The German expansion was the principal reason for French and Russian measures in 1913 and 1914. The French returned to three year military service. This was presented as a response to the threat of an immediate German attack. The Balkan Wars and the German law also inspired the Russians to accelerate their own armaments, but the sheer inefficiency of government and command made the proposed plans slow to take effect.

Chapter 7: The European Armies and the Outbreak of the First World War

This dispute revolved around Austria-Hungary's desire to exact a heavy retribution from Serbia for its involvement in the plot to kill Archduke Franz Ferdinand. Russia, backed by France, objected to extremes being inflicted on Serbia, while Berlin supported Austria-Hungary in its intention to take the opportunity for dealing a lasting blow against the Serbians.

The growth in the military strength of the Entente and Balkan armies made them appear to leaders in Germany and Austria-Hungary as if they would become a major danger in a few more years, and yet there still seemed to be a reasonable change of defeating them in a present war.

This was all accompanied by the growing acceptance of the notion of fighting a preventative war to forestall a worse situation in the future.

The Balance of Military Power in 1914

While Germany and Austria-Hungary had made significant expansions since 1911, the Entente had also drawn closer together, becoming more ready for war.

The French preparations for the imminent war also caused problems. The implementation of the three-year law caused more dislocation than anything else by the time the July crisis arrived. Also, the Germans had caught up with the French, for practical reasons, in the technological areas where France had enjoyed a margin of superiority. Most notoriously, the French didn't fix the problem of a modern field uniform. The blue-gray, with French national overtones, helped to make the prospect of a gray more palatable, but the law passed for a uniform of this color did not pass until July 9, 1914.

The main change in Russia, the "Great Program," did not pass in the Duma until June 1914 and the British army experienced almost no chance since 1912.

The Italian army was incapable of putting an army together at this point because of their long Libyan campaign.

The Baltic armies grew dramatically after the Balkan Wars. The South Slav forces especially did, because they gained experience, equipment, and new territory in the Balkan Wars.

Interesting "What If": What if Schlieffen had lived through the war?

The Balance of Military Power and the Decision for War

All of the great powers spent the July crisis trying to avoid a general war in Europe.