"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Monday, October 25, 2010

Strikwerda, Schroeder, Strikwerda

I feel like I understand how to read an article much beter than I did before. That seems completely justified when you see the stack that is sitting in the milk crate next to my desk. Piles and piles. I don't know if I like it. I tend to read things more quickly than I used to, and I feel like I am missing a lot by doing it. Maybe, after I get a break (ha!), I will return to absorbing everything.

Last Thursday, we were asked to examine three things when we read these articles:
  1. how they interact with the readings from Thursday,
  2. how they work together, and
  3. how historians debate.

They interact well with the readings from Thursday. All focus largely on the economic basis for the war. The articles from Thursday focus primarily on domestic fiscal policy while the Strikwerda and Schroeder series focus on the international economy.

The articles work quite well together, themselves, because they are a debate. I love the language of historical debate. There is clearly conflict, but it's almost nonconflicting. The author's describe each other's work as "interesting," "provacative," and "thougthful." I'm pretty sure those are not the words they said in their head while examining the work for the first time.

(I clumped these three articles together because they were not that long and they fit together. I hope that's okay.)

The first article, The Troubled Origins of European Economic Intergration: International Iron and Steel and Labor Migration in the Era of World War I by Carl Strikwerda, argues that "a high level of economic integrtion already existed in Western Europe on the eve of the war." He suggests that his arguement might bring about a new periodization of the twentieth century based on economic integration. Constantly thoughtout the article, he mentions the lack of previous research in this particular area. He asks an interesting question: "Which trend was growing faster in the last years before July 1914: peaceful integration or nationalistic militarism?"

The second article, a response to Strikwerda's, is titled Economic Integration and the European International System in the Era of World War I. It was written by Paul Schroeder. Schroeder agrees with Strikwerda's "course of European economic integration." He does not agree with the "suggestive interpretation of the actual and potential effects of this economic integreatino on the subsequent course of twentieth-century international history." He says positive things about the article, mentioning how it is valuable for historiographical purposes. Schroeder doesn't like how Strikwerda separates economic integration and nationalism into two distict trends. He claims that the leader's of the time did not think of things in that way and that the war itself is to be blaimed on the structure of international politics (and a major war was inevitable despite the "international cooperation in the economic field").

The last article, Strikwerda's response to Schroeder, is quite plainly called Response to "Economic Integration and the European International System in the Era of World War I." This is where I first noticed the interesting language. Schroeder begins his response by calling Schoeder's response a "thoughtful comment." I'm not sure if I am reading too far into this, but while thoughtful seems positive, the word comment could easily have a negative connotation. Strikwerda wants to take a look at whether European leaders actually believed that political and military power were essential to economic success. He states that leaders had a conflicting interpretations, but in general they tended to believe that "international economic power needed to rest on political and military intervention." He ends by stating that t"here is not inevitable about integration: it is a product of political decisions to allowe economies to grow in that direction."