First, I just have to type a line or two about the profound differences in these two articles. Ferguson immediately jumps into his argument, while Rowe takes numerous pages to prepare and give the complicated backdrop. I feel that both of the articles included the necessary introduction to prepare the reader for the argument adequately. They were both incredibly structured and easy to follow, though I do believe that Rowe went a little bit crazy with all of the points he was attempting to prove. Ferguson spends his entire article proving something that Rowe mentions almost as a footnote.
Ferguson's article "seeks to leave behind the somewhat sterile debate about international-verses-external primary by concentration on the point where foreign and domestic policies most clearly intersect: fiscal policy." He speculates that if Germany had been more militaristic then the First World War might have been less likely. Germany secured the orders that unleashed the conflict. This happened because the German leaders were frightened of the growing Russian and French military power and knew that they would not be able to fight back adequately if they hesitated any longer.
While being behind militarily, Germany was far from behind economically. Germany thus had the option to respond to the threats of their neighbors increasing their military power. Germany was spending (% of GDP) more than Britain and Austria-Hungary, but less than France and Russia. "Only domestic politics can explain why successive governments after 1895 failed to close that gap" (153).
The explanation lies (1) in the relationship between Prussia and the federal Reich. Prussia was the largest state of the 25 German states. Prussian bureaucrats got angry over the idea of expanding the German military. The conservative aversion to expansion was the main reason for the stagnation of the army's size between 1897 and 1912. Proposals for increased military spending threw into relief the defective nature of the Reich's political structure. (2) Another problem of Reich finance was the role of the Reichstag. The Reichstag's approval was needed if the government wanted to spend more on defense than the previously set among.
The Triple Entente were all centralized states with no more than two tiers of government. In Britain and in Germany political pressures had lead to increased social spending, this was not at the expense of military spending.
"Germany did not go to war to 'escape' from a domestic political crisis..." 163.
Ferguson concludes: "It therefore does seem legitimate to continue speaking of the war's domestic origins--even at the risk of drawing the paradoxical conclusion that increased military spending by Germany could have reduced the changes of a war in 1914." 168