I think I found my paper topic. Nye also wrote a book entitled Masculinity and Male Codes of Honor in Modern France (that just happens to be on Google books) that I will explore and then write my prospectus.
Nye begins dryly by introducing the purpose of his paper: "to introduce the principle that masculinities, like femininities and other forms of identity, are constructed." He builds on the Marxist principle that "men make their history (and themselves), but not exactly as they please" by stating that "when men consturt their masculinity they do it in particular economic contexts, within the conceptual constrints imposed by cultural and political traditions, in the crucible of social negotiation with other men and with women, and with a critical and appraising eye cast on alternative models of masculine behavior."
In the late 19th entury in France, there was a revival of the idea of honor. It was connected to a set of social and political values that adapted it to a new democratic order. This developed into a "powerful ideal of Republican manhood."
The leaders behind the Third Republic stressed the importance of a government that would "be socially moderate, implement economice and educational reform and unite the nation behind a crusade to reconquer the 'lost provinces' of Alsace and Lorraine."
Fencing and the duel experienced an enormous rise in popularity in the Third Republic. They were both "emblems of a new ideal of civic manhood." Anatole France called the sword, "the first tool of civilization, the only means man found to reconcile his brutal insticts and his ideal of justice." The new popularity of fencing was due to the rise in duelling, and both had been adopted by middle-class men.
Fencing halls were seen as a place that "civilized men and harmonized the classes." Fencers not only learned the steps and how to successfully win a duel, but also how to aviod conflict without "loss of honor of dignity." The fencing halls themselves evolved from nasty gym-like spaces into "tastefully outfitted" spaces.
An important political meaning was also read into fencing and the art of duel. Nye states it clearly: "Frencing and the duel served to dramatize and symbolically represent the principal idealogical components of Republicanism--individual liberty and equality--and therefore helped universalize and popularize the civic value system of the Third Republic."
Before concluding, Nye mentions the fact that fencing itself was not considered a sport until the late 1890s. The transitition of fencing from social activity to sport would meant the abondonment of the qualitites that many hoped fencing advocated.