"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Mombauer, 45-118

End of Part 1: The Question of War Guilt and during the War and at the Versailles Peace Negotiations

The German Innocence Campaign

Article 231 of the Treaty of Versailles both blamed Germany for the Great War and justified massive reparations. The agenda of the Germans was to exonerate themselves and place the blame on other nations.

Gottlieg von Jagow (in charge of foreign policy in 1914) blamed the war on both the Slavs and the Brits, for failing to contain the Slavs. Former Chancellor Bethmann Hollweg proclaimed that the decision for war had been taken by Germany's enemies, primarily Russia which failed to control Serbia and bring about a peaceful solution" (48). Former State Secretary of the Treasury Karl Helfferinch gave the blame almost entirely to Britain's imperialist aims. Unfortunately, these men were also caught saying incriminating things. Jagow told a friend that he could no longer sleep at night because he had "wanted the war" (49).

The Weimar government set up numerous official and semi-official bodies to help disprove Article 231. Some were the Parliamentary Committee of Inquiry, the Auswartiges Amt, the Center for Study of the Causes of the War, and the Working Committee of German Associations.

"...one reason why the debate has continued to divide historians to this day is precisely because it is indeed possible, with selective use of abailable evidence, to make a case for any of the major powers being responsible for war in 1914" (52).

The propaganda with which the German public faced was convincing. Most of the public though Germany clear from blame.

Official Document Collections

The first two nations to make their documents public were Russia, because the Bolshevik Party wanted the tsarist regime to take the blame, and Germany, because they wanted anyone but themselves to take the blame. The two nations did so in different ways. Russia made all of their documents public and Germany published a collection of dobuments. Russia was unique because it was the only nation that wanted to be blamed for the war. The German collection was called Die Grosse Politik (1922-27). Its documents were arranged in a thematic, rather than chronological order.

Once German released its "documents," the delayed release made it look as though Britain and France were hiding something. The British documents were published between 1926 and 1938 (The British Documents on the Origins of the War). They followed the same thematic pattern of Die Grosse Politik. France eventually published its documents too late to make much of an impact on any revisionist consensus (1930-53).

This section brought up an interesting conflict between historians and the government. While historians want to divuldge fact, governments desire propaganda.

Part 2: Revisionist and Anti-Revisionists

The German Quest for Revision of Versailles

As mentioned earlier, revisionalism was a uniting force for the people of Germany. Opposition to the tready helped unite the most disjointed groups in Weimar.

American Revisionists

The three main American revisionists were Fay, Barnes, and Owen. Barnes was actually convinced that America had gone into the war on the wrong side, despite the fact that the United States "fought...not in answer to a threat, but to defend the forces of light and goodness against the forces of darkness and evil" (84-Cohen).

European Revisionists

Edward Dene Morel is my favorite character from today's reading. Before the war, he opposed Britain's agreements with France and did not want any sort of conflict. Afterwards, he did not want to place the blame upon Germany. Morel was arrested for trying to send copies of his book Truth and the War abroad. I think that is very interesting because he was living in Britain. I feel like it would be resonable if he was living in Germany (well, I guess in Germany the book wouldn't have been published...). Morel said that the peace was "not constructive, but destructive" (92).

After Lloyd George's change of heart, the people of Britian no longer blamed Germany for the war. They believed that it was an act of fate.

A main reason why revisionist existed so prevalently was because the west needed Germany on their side against the encroaching shadow of now Soviet Russia.

Anti-Revisionists

Anti-revisionists are those that are convinced of German war guilt.

"Tens of thousands of diplomatic douments to read, the testimony of hundreds of witnesses to be sought oua dn criticised, a maze of controvery and debate to be traversed in quest of some occasional revelation of important - this is the tak of the historian who undertakes to attack as a whole the great problem of the origins of the World War" (104).

Intimidating! What a big task we have!

The Comfortable Consensus of the 1930s

"...attempts to put the responsibility for the war on one country were repalced by a new orthodoxy: the European nations had slithered into war through no real fault of their own...alliance systems and secret, 'old style diplomacy,' were the real culprits" (106).

I am compiling a list of ideas for the research paper. I will post it soon.