Part Three: Post Fischer Consensus and Continuing Debates
Nuances in the debate in the wake of the Fischer Controversy
There were three main interpretations that emerged after the Fischer controversy: Germany went to war in 1914 due to ambitious foreign policy aims, the domestic situation of the German state determined foreign policy, and that Germany wanted to preserve its freedom and action and embarked on calculated risk in 1914. The media was continually involved in this discussion because it is a large part of German identity.
Sturmer says that German history before the war was shaped by what he calls the "German dilemma." The German people needed a strong nation state as a guarantee against future invasions because of their location in the "strategic heartland" of Europe (179).
I really like the idea that Germany had no choice but to become a great power (because of their location). Otherwise, it would have been swallowed by the other powers surrounding it.
In times of international crisis, collective responsibility for the outbreak of the war was emphasized in many quarters.
Assessing the Role of Other Belligerent Powers in 1914
Austria
William says that decisions take in Vienna wre consciously designed to lead to war, because war would help Austria's internal and external problems.
Great Britain
GB didn't make their intentions clear enough in their support of France and Belgium. I have a feeling that we'll talk about this in a lot more detail towards the end of theis class.
France
It was assumed that France had been preparing for war since they lost Alsace-Lorraine to Germany in 1870. France wanted to stand by Russian ally against Germany aggression. Paleologue's role was also discussed in some detail.
Russia
German propaganda during and after thw war claimed taht the Russian mobilization had made further diplomatic attempts at a peaceful solution to the July Crisis impossible. Ironically enough, sources from the German archives prove thier own propaganda wrong. It is also argued that Russia's role as protector of the slavs could have possibily lead to escalation.
Serbia
Most historians don't give Serbia much thought. Cornwall says that Belgrad's role was more decisive than we think. Remak calls WWI a Third Balkan War. They had Russia on their saide and hoped that with the Russian assistance they would win a war against Austria.
Is Fischer's focus too narrow? Did it focus too much on Germany and not enough on other nations?
The Debate at the End of the 20th Century
...and the argument continues...even though most people still agree with Fischer.