"History is an argument without end." Pieter Geyl

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Joll/Martel 12-48: The July Crisis 1914,

I didn't have the wrong edition, I just hadn't gotten this book in the mail yet. I went down today and it was in my box! Perfect timing!

The second chapter of Joll/Martel (The July Crisis, 1914) summarizes itself quite well on page 41: "An account such as that attemped in this cahpter may explain the chronology of events and expound the official actions and statements of members of governments, ambassadors and soldiers, but it cannot explain how they reached a situation in which the decisions they took seemed rational and inevitable, and it certainly does not explain how the public came to accept or even welcome the decision for war."

Grey describes the Austro-Hungarian note as "the most formidable doument I had ever seen addressed by one State to another was that independent" (18). Sazonov accused the Austro-Hungarians of "[setting] fire to Europe" (19).

The Austro-Hungarian government was getting mixed responses from Germany. Moltke and William were telling people different things. This leads to the much asked question: Who was actually in charge? (25-26)

I really do believe that if the British had made up their mind earlier, they could have stopped the war. This, however, does not really matter. Asking "what if" questions are fun, but don't really lead to any progressive thought. Buchanan repeated Sazonov's words by saying, "If we [the British] took our stand firmly with France and Russia there would be no war" (26).

The case of the called bluff:
The Austrians thought that action against Serbia plus German support would deter Russia.
Russians thought that a show of their strength against Austria would check Austria and scare away the Germans.

How public opinion matters:
Policies had to be presented in "such a way as to justify the war" (36).
The terms and timing of war declarations were determined by the efforts of the government to "present themselves in the best light as to justify their actions to their citizens..." (41).

"We know when and why a war starts but never where it stops" (43). Russian representative in Belgrade to Autrian colleague.

The following statement is made just before the close of the second chapter: "...July 1914 remains a major historiographical and philosophical problem that may indeed be insoluble" (44). This is true, but I like the attitude taken by Joll/Martel: that this is a fun and interesting subject that should not be forgotten but continually reevaluated.