The introduction to Mombauer's The Origins of the First World War: Controversies and Consensus was an organized and concise overview of long and short term causes of the war (1870-1914). I was surprised when, on page 14, there was a long block quote (Szogyeny) followed by what was essentially a summarization, not analysis, of the quote by Mombauer. I often struggle trying to sum up the ending of a block quote and am sure that repeating the contents is not the way to go.
"There is no interpretation, no 'factual' account of the events that lead to the war that could not be criticized or rejected by historians that favor a different explanation of the origins of the war-after all, that is why this debate has occupied historians for nearly a century" (17).
This warning was necessary and almost humerus. Mombauer's brief summary of the long and short term causes of the war seemed incredibly unbiased to me, but it could seem baised to others. Also, the transition from introduction to Part 1 reminded me of Wiess's discussion in Core yesterday. I think that is going to happen a lot this year.
I really like how blunt and straightforward Mombauer is during introductions. It reminds me a lot of the text I read for fresh focus, The End of the Bronze Age (Drew). Both Mombauer and Drew plainly state exactly what they are about to focus on. In the Introduction to Origins, Mombauer breaks the books into three parts and briefly describes what will occur in each section. Much like Mombauer, Drew plainly states multiple times, "The thesis of this is _____." So far, I am enjoying the accessibility of this book.
The beginning of the debate of the War's origins is the first portion of Part 1. This portion sparked an interest within me for the colored books. At this time, everyone was on the defensive, trying to throw blame on others. I'd really like to read them, especially the white (because propaganda is fun). It's incredibly ironic that the Germans picked the color white.
"Brilliant mood. The government has succeeded very well as making us appear as the attacked" (23). German Admiral von Muller
At least in WWI, there were Germans fighting back. They still had the ability and the lack of fear/free will to do so. The Lichnowsky memorandum is a good example: "Lichnowsky knows what we are fighting about. Thousands in Germany know what we are fighting about, and millions soon will know" (30).
The second portion of Part 1 is The Versailles war guilt allegation. It follows the "paper warfare" at Versailles. The main factor of the treaty that the Germans did not want to accept (and did not end up accepting) is the blame for the start of the war.
"The demand is made that we shall acknowledge that we alone are guilty of having caused the war. Such a confession in my mouth would be a lie" (39). Brockdorff-Rantzau
And now, says Mombauer, the "debate...began in earnest" (45).